Loading...
HOME2023-01-22T13:43:33-07:00

Damn, there is so much great knowledge out there. Did you know that “BOOKS” are full of smart?? No, I mean like life changing, I-wish-I-knew-that-years-ago type stuff.

I know that I was waaaayyy late to the game figuring it out. And I know that a lot of you are too busy to read as much as you ‘should’. And that is why you need me.

I still remember how it started for me. It started in June of 2008. After 11  years …..Click to continue

Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/19/26 {{catlist}}
May 19, 2026
READ MORE **WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/19/2026** UMBS opened softer as global headline noise failed to spark dip buying. Current stacks show UMBS 30yr 5.0 at 97.16 (-0.26), 5.5 at 99.55 (-0.12), and 6.0 at 101.40 (-0.12). The tone is risk off for conventionals, but ranges remain tight. Expect modest rate sheet pressure on conventional best ex. GNMA liquidity looks steadier with a small edge versus conventionals. GNMA 30yr prints: 5.0 at 97.80 (+0.02), 5.5 at 99.84 (+0.06), and 6.0 at 101.34 (-0.06). That mix implies slightly firmer FHA/VA pricing at mid coupons with a touch of weakness up in coupon. Servicer bids and prepay expectations are keeping Ginnie basis contained. Treasuries are a bit weaker, consistent with “bombarded by headlines, but little changed.” The 10-year is around 4.618% (+2.9 bps) with the belly leading modestly. Front-end yields are up roughly 3–4 bps while the long bond lags, a small bear-steepening. With no data on tap, flows and technicals are doing most of the work. For lock desks, conventional rate sheets likely come out a few bps worse versus Monday’s close. Government pricing may hold better at production coupons given the slight Ginnie outperformance. Pipeline hedgers should watch for midday reprice risk if the 10-year pushes further above 4.62%. Extension costs remain sticky with volatility still elevated on headline risk. A credible geopolitical de-escalation headline could unlock a friendlier rate path, but timing is unknowable. Stay nimble and keep hedges sized for headline whipsaws. Monitor liquidity pockets around the lunch lull for potential reprice windows. **Locking vs Floating** Bonds show resilience but have not displayed conviction to buy dips without a clear catalyst, arguing for a defensive bias on floats. A peaceful resolution in the Middle East would be rate friendly, yet timing is unknowable, so do not anchor lock decisions to that hope. Use UMBS for intraday risk cues, but lean on 10-year yield levels to gauge bigger-picture momentum and set guardrails. **Today's Events** No scheduled economic data or key events on the calendar. **Bond Pricing** **UMBS 30 yr** | Coupon | Price | Intra-Day Change | | 5.0 | 97.16 | -0.26 | | 5.5 | 99.55 | -0.12 | | 6.0 | 101.4 | -0.12 | **GNMA 30 yr** | Coupon | Price | Intra-Day Change | | 5.0 | 97.8 | 0.02 | | 5.5 | 99.84 | 0.06 | | 6.0 | 101.34 | -0.06 | **Treasuries** | Term | Yield | Price | Intra-Day Yield Change | | 2 yr | 4.079 | 99.612 | 0.033 | | 3 yr | 4.152 | 98.178 | 0.035 | | 5 yr | 4.273 | 98.227 | 0.039 | | 7 yr | 4.443 | 98.848 | 0.037 | | 10 yr | 4.618 | 96.089 | 0.029 | | 30 yr | 5.147 | 93.966 | 0.022 | Market Data
Is UWM the Next Countrywide? The Two Harbors Saga Just Exposed a $100 Million Problem Nobody Saw Coming {{catlist}}
May 19, 2026
READ MORE
 

Is UWM the Next Countrywide? The Two Harbors Saga Just Exposed a $100 Million Problem Nobody Saw Coming


Today is the day Two Harbors shareholders vote. By the time you read this, one of the two largest stories in the mortgage industry this year may already be settled. But even if the vote is done, the story is not. Because in the final days before this shareholder meeting, two major developments landed that have nothing to do with which company gets RoundPoint — and everything to do with the question of whether the economics underneath UWM's business model are as solid as Mat Ishbia says they are.

The first development came from Wall Street. The second came from a New York City courtroom. Together, they paint a picture every mortgage professional needs to understand.

What the Two Harbors Board Said — and Why It Matters

We covered the bidding war timeline in our last post, but here is what you need to know about the board's final rejection of UWM's $12.50 offer. The Two Harbors board did not simply say the price was not right. They said the entire offer structure was designed to deceive.

Their argument: UWM advertises $12.50 per share in cash, but the default for any shareholder who does not proactively elect cash is UWM stock — worth approximately $7.58 per share as of last Monday's close. The board estimated up to 30% of shareholders could end up in that scenario, and accused UWM of knowing this and structuring the deal deliberately to take advantage of it. The board also noted that UWM's $12.50 bid was not backed by an increase in its financing commitment from Mizuho Bank, leaving questions about whether an all-cash close is actually funded.

In contrast, the board pointed to CrossCountry's $12 all-cash deal as the only offer shareholders can trust to get over the finish line — citing 35 of 53 required regulatory approvals already secured, a signed agreement, and an August 2026 close target.

The board's language was unusually sharp for a corporate press release. "Illusory, predatory and unactionable" is not the kind of language boards use unless they want shareholders to understand exactly how they feel. Positions have hardened. And the ISS recommendation telling shareholders to vote against the CrossCountry deal — issued just days before the vote — means neither side was heading into Monday with any comfort.

The Countrywide Question

Beyond the tactical back-and-forth, a more significant conversation has been building in analyst circles, and it is not staying quiet anymore.

Christopher Whalen, chairman of Whalen Global Advisors and one of the most credible voices in mortgage market analysis, published a detailed piece comparing UWM's competitive strategy to Countrywide Financial. That is not a casual comparison. Countrywide is the name that still makes mortgage veterans flinch. Under CEO Angelo Mozilo, Countrywide used aggressive loss-leader pricing to dominate market share — the strategy looked brilliant right up until the moment the whole structure collapsed in 2008 and forced an involuntary sale to Bank of America.

Whalen's argument is not that UWM is creating subprime loans or repeating the specific mistakes of 2008. The products are different. But the strategic logic, he argues, looks familiar. UWM has been pricing aggressively in the wholesale channel to drive volume, accepting compressed margins in exchange for market dominance. The result has been a gain-on-sale margin environment across the industry that has gotten painfully thin — one industry insider told Whalen that if UWM disappeared tomorrow, gain-on-sale margins across the mortgage sector would at least double.

The specific data point that has analysts paying close attention involves UWM's mortgage servicing rights portfolio. Whalen's research found that as of Q1 2026, UWM appeared to be valuing its MSR book at over 5.5 times annual cash flows. The actual market for similar MSR transactions right now is running closer to 4.8 times for conventional assets and lower for government loans. If UWM were forced to sell its MSR portfolio at true market value, the write-down could exceed $1 billion — which would potentially eliminate more than two-thirds of the company's equity. The Two Harbors board cited this analysis directly in its rejection letter.

UWM pushed back hard and reported strong Q1 2026 numbers: $44.9 billion in origination volume, up 39% year over year, and net income of $170.4 million. Mat Ishbia called it the second-best first quarter in company history. He has consistently and colorfully dismissed critics who focus on MSR fair-value accounting as people who simply do not understand the mortgage business.

But the concerns are not going away. Two Fitch downgrades in six months. Cash declining from $503 million to $424 million in a single quarter. Leverage at an all-time company high of 3.2 times. Bloomberg's one-year probability of default calculation for UWM doubling in just three weeks. These are the numbers Two Harbors' board is pointing at when they call UWM's offer "illusory."

Then Came the Lawsuit Nobody Expected

And then, on Thursday, a $100 million lawsuit landed in New York Supreme Court.

Rocket Mortgage — now the owner of Mr. Cooper following its $14.2 billion acquisition completed last October — filed suit against UWM, alleging breach of contract tied to a series of mortgage servicing rights transactions that happened between January and June of 2024.

Here is what happened, according to the lawsuit. Mr. Cooper purchased from UWM the servicing rights to nearly 182,000 loans with a combined unpaid principal balance of approximately $65 billion. Mr. Cooper paid $773 million for those rights. Embedded in the three purchase agreements was a non-solicitation covenant — a contractual promise that UWM would not solicit those borrowers to refinance away from Mr. Cooper's servicing platform.

Rocket alleges UWM did exactly the opposite.

According to the complaint, UWM launched multiple programs targeting those very borrowers. The "Refi75" program cut refinance rates by 75 basis points across the board without excluding borrowers in the loan pools sold to Mr. Cooper. A program called "Refi Shield 100" — a 100-basis-point pricing incentive launched shortly after Rocket announced it would acquire Mr. Cooper — allegedly targeted the same borrowers. UWM's AI-powered "KEEP" technology, which identifies refinance opportunities among current and former UWM customers, is alleged to have been used to surface leads from those exact portfolios without excluding them.

The lawsuit also quotes Ishbia directly from a March 2025 sales call with UWM brokers, telling them to go refinance every loan that UWM had ever sold to Mr. Cooper. During an internal "Weekly Fastbreak" video, Ishbia reportedly told brokers he would "lose money just for fun" to keep those loans away from Rocket. The lawsuit describes him putting a "bounty" on the loans so they would never end up in Rocket's hands. The result, Rocket alleges, was a prepayment rate on those serviced loan pools running 2.5 times higher than comparable portfolios — costing Rocket nearly $100 million in lost servicing income.

UWM called the lawsuit "baseless and opportunistic" and questioned its timing. A company spokesperson noted that the filing came shortly after a former Rocket executive joined the broker community as a UWM partner. "The timing speaks for itself," the spokesperson said.

What This All Means for You

Let's connect the dots for loan officers and real estate agents, because these threads are not separate stories. They are parts of the same story.

UWM's pricing strategy has been one of the most powerful competitive tools in the wholesale broker channel. When UWM offers the sharpest prices in the market, brokers win business they could not win otherwise. That is real value. Nobody is disputing that.

But that pricing has to be paid for somewhere. UWM's own first-quarter earnings, which Ishbia called the second best in company history, came with a cash position that declined by nearly $80 million in a single quarter. The leverage number is at an all-time high. Analysts are now asking publicly whether the MSR book is being valued at a level that reflects reality. And a $100 million lawsuit just dropped, alleging that UWM's effort to reclaim loans it had already sold to a competitor — at a loss, by its own CEO's admission — constituted a willful breach of contract.

None of that means UWM is going to collapse. They are the largest wholesale lender in the country, originating nearly $45 billion in a single quarter. But the pattern of behavior — aggressive pricing, elevated leverage, disputed asset valuations, and now an open legal fight over loans Ishbia apparently wanted to retrieve at any cost — looks like a company operating under serious competitive pressure. The mortgage industry does not have many precedents for what that looks like at this scale.

The Two Harbors vote today will decide who gets RoundPoint. Whatever that outcome is, the questions raised during this saga are not going away with it.

Well That Makes Sense exists to translate moments like this one into something you can actually use. If you want to understand the industry at a level most of your competitors never will, subscribing to the blog is the lowest-effort, highest-return thing you can do today. Consider it professional development — just with fewer boring speakers and way more useful information. Subscribe at www.WellThatMakesSense.com. underneath these headlines.

 
Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/18/26 {{catlist}}
May 18, 2026
READ MORE **WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/18/2026** The New York Federal Reserve manufacturing index exploded to 19.60 in May, crushing the 7.5 forecast and signaling unexpected economic strength that sent bond yields higher across the curve. Industrial production also beat expectations with a 0.7% gain in April versus the 0.3% forecast, reversing prior weakness and fueling fears that inflation pressures may intensify. These hotter-than-expected data points arrive amid elevated crude oil prices holding above $100 per barrel, driven by uncertainty surrounding the Iran conflict and the Strait of Hormuz. The combination of stronger growth and energy-driven inflation concerns has markets pricing in a 60-40 probability of a Federal Reserve rate hike by January, forcing mortgage professionals to monitor geopolitical risk alongside domestic economics. Bond yields drifted weaker intraday despite the hawkish data, with Treasury curves showing modest volatility as investors digest the inflation implications. Mortgage originators face mounting cost pressures as per-loan origination costs climbed to $11,898 in Q1 2026 from $11,102 in Q4 2025, highlighting the competitive squeeze between pricing and production efficiency. The CFPB remains a significant regulatory force despite prior Administration statements suggesting reductions, as the bureau requested funding exceeding $140 million for fiscal 2026 and continues advancing discrete rulemaking initiatives. Current CFPB priorities include addressing loan officer compensation structures, finalizing the servicing rule, refining ability-to-repay standards, and streamlining refinance documentation requirements. The MBA is collaborating with the agency on credit modernization discussions that question traditional tri-merge credit reporting and pilot programs under review by the FHFA. Mortgage professionals should expect continued regulatory evolution around AI governance, vendor oversight, and consumer data usage, as demonstrated by scheduled industry panels at MBA Secondary addressing legal and compliance realities. Compliance teams must stay aligned with evolving agency expectations rather than assuming deregulatory momentum. Housing affordability remains a structural headwind as U.S. Homeowners with mortgages now pay 37 percent more per month than renters, forcing prospective borrowers toward difficult choices including potential relocation for affordable property. LendingTree data highlights that rental markets outperform ownership costs in every major metropolitan area, even in the tightest housing markets, due to elevated mortgage rates and home prices. This affordability crisis creates opportunity in reverse mortgages and home equity tapping solutions, given that $14.5 trillion in senior home equity remains largely untapped by traditional refinance programs. Mortgage professionals operating in origination-constrained environments should explore alternative products and client segments that address specific affordability barriers and liquidity needs. The shift toward equity extraction and non-traditional loan products reflects realistic adaptation to persistent rate and price headwinds. Capital markets remain dominated by geopolitical risk over domestic economic data, as oil prices and Iran conflict developments drive investor sentiment and bond yields far more than traditional inflation metrics or Fed policy signals. Treasury yields hold elevated levels near year-to-date highs following last week's selloff on hot consumer and producer price prints combined with climbing energy costs. Market participants are increasingly focused on April FOMC meeting minutes scheduled for release this week to assess committee debate on the path of policy prior to Fed Chairman Kevin Warsh's recent swearing-in. The question of whether committee members view the next move as equally likely to be a rate cut versus a rate hike will carry amplified weight given recent inflation surprises. Until geopolitical tensions ease or energy prices stabilize, rate volatility and mortgage rate uncertainty should be expected. **Locking vs Floating** Yield ceilings and floors have proved useful for tracking broader bond market momentum, particularly when sharp breakouts test levels unseen for a year. A peaceful resolution to the Iran conflict would likely push rates lower, but the timeline remains unknowable and dependent on developments outside traditional economic forecasting. Borrowers should remain cautious about floating rate locks until clarity emerges on energy markets and geopolitical trajectories. **Today's Events** NY Fed Manufacturing (May): 19.60 vs 7.5 forecast, 11.00 previous Industrial Production (April): 0.7% vs 0.3% forecast, -0.5% previous **Bond Pricing** **UMBS 30 yr** | Coupon | Price | Intra-Day Change | | 5.0 | 97.35 | -0.06 | | 5.5 | 99.69 | -0.02 | | 6.0 | 101.61 | 0.05 | **GNMA 30 yr** | Coupon | Price | Intra-Day Change | | 5.0 | 98.09 | 0 | | 5.5 | 100.17 | -0.1 | | 6.0 | 101.57 | 0 | **Treasuries** | Term | Yield | Price | Intra-Day Yield Change | | 2 yr | 4.077 | 99.617 | -0.009 | | 3 yr | 4.142 | 98.206 | -0.001 | | 5 yr | 4.256 | 98.299 | 0.008 | | 7 yr | 4.424 | 98.963 | 0.009 | | 10 yr | 4.596 | 96.259 | 0.001 | | 30 yr | 5.125 | 94.285 | 0.007 | Market Data
LATEST ARTICLES

RECENT ARTICLES

Mortgage Today (AM) – 05/19/26

May 19th, 2026|Week In Review|

**WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/19/2026** UMBS opened softer as global headline noise failed to spark dip buying. Current stacks show UMBS 30yr 5.0 at 97.16 (-0.26), 5.5 at [...]

Mortgage Today (AM) – 05/18/26

May 18th, 2026|Week In Review|

**WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/18/2026** The New York Federal Reserve manufacturing index exploded to 19.60 in May, crushing the 7.5 forecast and signaling unexpected economic strength that sent [...]

Article Archive

Mortgage Today (PM) – 05/15/26

May 15th, 2026|0 Comments

**WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (PM) - 05/15/2026** Mortgage-backed securities plunged 0.75 points Friday as global uncertainty over Iran tensions and persistent inflation fears sent Treasury yields soaring to one-year highs. [...]

Mortgage Today (AM) – 05/15/26

May 15th, 2026|0 Comments

**WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/15/2026** The afternoon bond rally collapsed on Thursday, leaving mortgage securities and Treasuries sharply weaker heading into Friday. UMBS 30-year prices fell across all [...]

Mortgage Today (AM) – 05/14/26

May 14th, 2026|0 Comments

**WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/14/2026** MBS rallied strongly overnight after initially selling off when producer prices crushed forecasts, with the 30-year UMBS 5.0 coupon gaining 22 basis points [...]

Mortgage Today (PM) – 05/13/26

May 13th, 2026|0 Comments

**WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (PM) - 05/13/2026** Mortgage-backed securities staged a stunning intraday recovery after hotter-than-expected inflation data briefly sent markets reeling this morning. The April PPI report shocked traders [...]

Mortgage Today (AM) – 05/13/26

May 13th, 2026|0 Comments

**WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/13/2026** War headlines and auction concessions have pushed 10-year Treasury yields to their highest level in 10 months, signaling stronger headwinds for mortgage originators. [...]

Mortgage Today (PM) – 05/12/26

May 12th, 2026|0 Comments

**WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (PM) - 05/12/2026** War headlines pushed bond markets to their worst levels in 10 months as geopolitical tensions triggered aggressive selling across both MBS and Treasuries. [...]

Mortgage Today (AM) – 05/12/26

May 12th, 2026|0 Comments

WTMS Blog Today = What's up in Mortgage Today (AM) - 05/12/2026 Mortgage-backed securities retreated from morning highs as geopolitical tensions overshadowed April's surprisingly hot inflation data. The 30-year UMBS 5.0 coupon fell nearly 0.17 [...]

Subscribe

Send me some brain food

Go to Top